Main Messages Conveyed to the Indians by Clarks Address Essay - 2

Main Messages Conveyed to the Indians by Clarks Address - Essay Example It is evidently clear from the discussion that the language Clark uses in addressing the Indians is significant. He refers to them as â€Å"children†. This was done to establish a position of authority over them. He indicates that the Great Chief would take care of them, just like a father would care for his child, but only if they are obedient to the Great Chief. In modern times, this type of speech would be considered very demeaning if directed from one culture to another. In defense of Clark, he probably was mimicking the type of speech he thought the Indians would understand and react to in a positive manner. The researcher states that some of the Indians probably did react in a positive way to Clark’s message. The lure of more luxury items and better housing would have been a great incentive for some Indians. But other Indians would have been resistant to the message. Not all Indian cultures were the same. Some place a greater value on acts of bravery and warfare t han on having luxury items. They would have probably rejected the offer to visit with the Great Chief. President Jackson justifies the removal of the Cherokee Nation to the lands west of the Mississippi River in several ways. He argues that this removal will be good for the United States and the Cherokee Nation. It will be good for the Cherokee Nation because it will allow them to be free of the control of the states. They will be removed to lands that they can inhabit and call their own. They will be able to run their own governments, practice their own traditional religion and preserve their culture from destruction by the white man. He also argues that the Indians will benefit because the government is going to pay for the entire cost of their resettlement. He goes on to state that through philanthropy, the United States had attempted to help their tribes, but they would not respond to the help.